I’m more prone to turn off the TV…
Apr 09, 2010In case you’re one of the handful of people out there that hasn’t seen or heard the news, Nike just launched an ad featuring Tiger Woods, only days before his highly anticipated return to golf for the Masters. And if you are one of those people, let me save you some time: it sucks! It is absolutely horrible – do not waste your time watching it!!
The spot is ridiculous. I won’t go into detail about all of the reasons why it’s ridiculous because you’ve probably heard them already: it’s creepy; you don’t know who the voice in the background belongs to; it has nothing to do with Nike; Tiger’s father shouldn’t be a moral compass for anyone. You get it.
Lots of people are giving Nike credit for being courageous for putting out such a controversial spot. Donny Deutsch appeared on The Today Show yesterday and said, “Most advertisers would not have hit it head on…I think it is the most brilliantly stunning move I have seen in a long time.”
Are you serious?? Give me a break!! The only thing brave or courageous about putting out a spot like this is on the agency’s part because they are putting themselves in imminent danger of being FIRED when the spot is a complete and utter failure!!
Tiger is a spokesperson for Nike. His job is to represent and promote the Nike brand. This spot in no way, shape or form does that. Even if you like the commercial (which gives me serious cause for concern if you do), is it really going to make you want to run out and buy a new pair of Nike tennis shoes or a set of golf clubs? No!! Instead, this spot seems more like a continuation of the ongoing public awareness campaign issued from Tiger’s camp in an attempt to repair his image. It’s absurd.
I don’t know who is more to blame here – the agency for creating this spot, or Nike for approving it! It doesn’t really matter – it’s a lose-lose situation for both of them. And as long as we’re going down that road, I might as well point out that it’s another huge mistake for Tiger as well. He needs to make up his mind: either focus on his golf game and keep his personal life out of it; or continue trying to repair his public image by beating a dead horse over and over again. I’ve completely lost respect for him either way. But at least pick an option and stick to it.
I CONCUR!
I usually agree with your blog posts and respect you professional opinion but today I completely disagree with you. You are obvisouly still talking about the ad and promoting it on your blog…so it has done its job in becoming viral. Whether it sells more Nike clubs, hats, bags, balls, etc. we will determine that when the sales numbers are released. Numbers don’t lie! Whether the commercial was the best one in town or not you would have never given it the respect it deserves becuase as you said…” I’ve completely lost respect for him either way”. With that biased opinion of the man, there is no way you can make an accurate and professional judgement of his commercials. Oh and if he wins this weekend, which is looking very possible, Nike will sell more golf products than ever before. Mark my words.
I don’t agree with his transgressions but he deserves a second chance to prove himself to his fans and to his sponsors…not to mention to his wife and family. I’m cheering for him and hoping he can learn from this experience and become a better man moving forward. To hate on him for something he didn’t do directly to you, is just plain feeble. Thanks for providing this blog for all of us to voice our opinion on these issues.
I am 20 years old and I may not have the experience of life that most people older then me do but after watching this commercial I thought it was a nice concept. Although I thought it was a nice concept, it still sucked. If you really knew Tiger’s history and had been following the media frenzy surrounding his recent scandal, you would know that most reporters and people believe that his father played a major role in his negative behavior. Even before this scandal became public I would always hear stories about how bad of a person Tiger’s father was. I agree with you JZ. DM me on twitter, would love to have a conversation with you. 20 years old, you’re my role model.